Truing 2008 R1200GS Rim

Hello,

Total rebuild, using original parts:
– rear rim was under 1mm laterally (round) and no great than 1.5mm horizontal (left to right). 2008 R1200GS rim that had manufacturers defects and a lot of abuse.
– front rim was under 1.5mm laterally (round) and no great than 1.7mm horizontal (left to right). This rim that had manufacturers defects as well with more abuse, so even spoke tension is not where I would like it but even new wheels are not that great.

I tried all my different wheel building methods but only the truespoke worked. Any traditional wheel correction methods only made the tolerance worse.

I have been build High end bicycle wheels since 2000 as a national level Cycling coach and ex athlete. From down hill, road and endurance MTB racing, I have worked with all different alloys and carbon fiber including the original zipp 404. I have never seen a worse wheel to true than the BMW, almost ridiculous.

The best method I used was to sit comfortably with the wheel on my lap and follow your procedure, only use the screwdriver type handle. I would double/triple check each rotation before moving to the other side. I would also check progress on even spoke tension by ear and make certain any tension deviation was not from wrong measurements. I allowed a -/+0.05 mm tolerance on the required measurements with some exceptions (old parts) and this allowed some room to gain a little more even spoke tension. I would only use the trueing stand after each spoke had been completely checked and rechecked, any deviations were usually my fault or known manufacturers defects. Once nearly completed, now using a small 3/8 T-handle, I would check torque of the nipples (pick a reference, they seem to be all different) and make certain they are above minimum setting. I used 3Nm as a minimum reference but my ears were the main tool. All spokes seemed to be happily settled between 3-4Nm.

Lesson learnt:
On old wheels, Remove all nipples and clean them meticulously.
Clean all the nipple holes the same;
Used heavy oil or never seize on the nipple/hub mating surface, even Molybdenum EP-grease would be good;
Thread holes need to be clean but lubricated with a lighter oil (grease will throw oil measurements);
Spoke tension cannot be accurately tested by torque of the nipples. Without a proper spoke tension gauge (see park bicycle tools) I could only trust my ears (old school).

My down fall was trying to polish a turd (to quote Jerry Lewis). On old wheels, I think anything within manufacturers specs is excellent and 2mm would be ok for old off road type wheels. My old off road wheels are just in spec, still not to my specifications, and have no observable on road handling issues low or high speed.
Spoke tension is my most concern. Over the years of racing, I have found too little tension breaks spokes, to much breaks hubs/rims. To little tension will let the wheel over flex and work harden, the already brittle, stainless steel spoke.
Mavic wheels were notorious for this reason but if the tension was too much, the rim would pull through (circa 2000-2010).

Sincerely,
John

ELECTRO MECHANICAL
Commercial & Industrial Electrical & Mechanical, electromechanical engineering systems, Marine/Automotive/Motorcycle Electrical and Mechanical, Electronic Peripherals, Hydraulic/Pneumatics, power Generation (Electrical and Mechanical), Motors, Solar, Data, Security Consultant, Air-conditioning/Refrigeration, Defense Contracts and more.

John
0